17 Apr 2019 3 min read

The curve that cried wolf

By James Carrick

The yield-curve boy is crying wolf, raising recession fears. But the villagers at central banks have responded to dangers already.

finger and graph

The ‘yield curve’ has inverted again, leading to a renewed wave of recession fearsThe yield curve is the difference between long and short-term interest rates and basically the market’s expectations for future Federal Reserve (Fed) policy.

Sometimes the wolf can be kept at bay... half of Fed easings have led to soft landings

Markets currently expect the Fed to cut interest rates by 35bp over the next 18 months. The Fed tends to cut interest rates when the economy is in trouble. But the Fed can deliver soft landings.

Since it began targeting the Fed Funds rate in 1982, half of the Fed’s easing cycles have delivered a soft landing (1984, 1995, 1998). The other half have ended in tears (1989, 2001, 2007). So sometimes the wolf can be kept at bay.

I previously used an analogy about the yield curve and umbrellas. If you think it’s going to rain, you take an umbrella to work. But taking an umbrella to work doesn’t by itself cause it to rain. Correlation is not causation.

Similarly, when investors fear a recession, they expect the Fed to cut rates. But markets pricing in rate cuts doesn’t by itself cause a recession. However, this analogy is too simplistic. There is another player involved – the central bank – and they can try and influence the weather.

Ahead of the 2008 Olympics, the Beijing authorities fired rockets into the sky to prevent it raining during the opening ceremony. Similarly, policymakers can try to prevent a recession if they fear a storm coming.

The villagers at the Fed, ECB and Chinese central banks have already responded to cries for help

Global economic data have been weak over the past six months while inflation has remained contained. In response, the Fed has already changed tack on its plans to raise interest rates this year. The Chinese government is pushing stimulus through and the European Central Bank (ECB) has announced another cheap-loan package for banks. Corporate bond yields and mortgage rates have fallen in response, echoing what happened in 2016. And there’s still further fiscal easing to come in the US.

So while recession models based purely on the yield curve are getting worse, alternative models are improving. We look at a range of indicators to assess recession likelihood. Using two of the most statistically-significant variables (credit-availability surveys and the change in private-sector interest gearing) suggests the probability of recession is receding.

A recession wolf did threaten the sheep at the end of 2018 as credit conditions tightened. The boy was right to cry for help. With inflation subdued, the villagers at the Fed, the ECB and Chinese government have heard the cries and come out to try and fend off the wolves, similar to what they did in 2016.

James Carrick

Global economist

James is a global economist with a knack for using analogies to explain economic concepts. He is a techno-optimist and an early adopter. He enjoys building models - both of the economy and robot Lego ones with his son. He also likes crunching data and chocolate bars. He joined in 2006 from the number-one ranked economics team at ABN AMRO with prior experience at HM Treasury.

James Carrick